Forest News Forest News
Ecology News
EcoSystem News
Environomics
desert news
forest news
grassland news
lake news
mountain news
ocean news
prairie news
river news
soil news
tundra news
water news
wetland news
Solar Today
Discovery Wire
EcoSage
Sponsors
Management
iNet News Team
Contact

Submit your own Articles
Dawn
of the
Solar Era
A
Wake Up
Call!
BioFuels:
Science or
Fiction?
How can we turn
sun radiation
into automotion?
Personal
Transportation
100% Solar Powered

Felling trees has sky-high price. Deforestation is drying out cloud forests. [Nature, 19 October 2001]
Forest Stewardship Council Certifies Plantations

A troubling fact has come to our attention: an increasing number of large-scale tree monocrops are receiving Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certification throughout the world.

Among the plantations recently given a "green" stamp of approval are Shell's plantations in Argentina, Chile, Paraguay and Uruguay; SAPPI's, MONDI's and SAFCOL's in South Africa; Klabin's and V&M Florestal's in Brazil; Perum Perhutani's in Indonesia; Fletcher Challenge's in New Zealand/Aotearoa and many others. If this trend continues, many more tree monocultures will also be guaranteed "sustainable" by the FSC, an organization which enjoys great credibility among the public.

The FSC was created as a result of increased awareness by consumers about their role in forest destruction, resulting from successful NGO campaigns, particularly regarding unsustainable logging practices in the tropics. When consumers began to ask their suppliers for certified wood, a number of NGOs decided to promote a process which could give them the choice of a "green" product. The NGOs came up with a number of principles and criteria that they insisted should be met before an FSC certificate was granted.

Nine of those principles are focused on forests and one on plantations (number 10). We believe that it is this decision -- to allow large-scale monoculture plantations to be certified along with other forestry operations -- which lies at the root of the current disturbing trend. People throughout the world are increasingly aware that plantations are not forests. Numerous local communities and organizations have documented the impacts of large-scale plantations and opposed them because of their social and environmental impacts. The plantations in question have resulted either in deforestation or in the degradation of other ecosystems, particularly grasslands and wetlands. On the ground reality is showing that large-scale tree monocultures -- no matter how many mitigation measures are implemented -- inevitably result in large-scale impacts on water, soils, flora, fauna and people because of their sheer scale.

Even if one accepts -- which we don't -- that plantations are forests, the fact is that Principle 10 is so weak that most plantations -- with the exception of those in areas marked by land conflict -- can be declared "sustainable" and given FSC certification.

We do not pretend to challenge the FSC and even less to question our NGO friends involved in it. What we do request is for them to revisit the whole issue of plantation certification, to take into account the plentiful existing documentation regarding the basic unsustainability of the plantation forestry model and either to exclude plantations from FSC certification altogether or to modify substantially Principle 10.

The FSC's main strength is its public credibility. Certification of unsustainable forestry operations -- such as large-scale tree monocultures -- can erode this credibility. A critical review of its own principles by the FSC can only increase it. We sincerely hope that the FSC will be able to accomplish the latter.

More in the World Rainforest Movement's Bulletin, February 2001

Johannesburg Summit. The iNet News Team is covering the World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg, South Africa. [August 2002]
Africa - US Energy Ministers meet again in Durban, South Africa for the Second Africa Energy Ministers Conference. The iNet News Team was there. [December 2000]
Porvenir, Bolivia. Village Power 2000 Team Bolivia installs solar powered satellite based internet connection in the remote community of Porvenir. [October 2000]
US - Africa Energy Ministers Meet. Representatives from over 40 countries from the continent of Africa converged on the city of Tucson for the U.S. – Africa Energy Ministers Conference. The iNet News Team was there. [December 1999]
Solar Light for Churches of Africa. The iNet News Team™ helped to install solar systems in Ugandan schools and clinics for lighting and computers. [July / August 1999]
The National Town Meeting for a Sustainable America. The iNet News Team™ has been to Detroit, and the Youth Delegates were heard! [May 1999]


The iNetNews Service, a multi-media, project-based, experiential learning program for students, is sponsored by SolarQuest® and the Earth Day Network. iNetNews Team correspondents (students with a demonstrated interest in sustainable energy) report on local, national, and international events.
Join students around the world on Earth Day to celebrate the quest to create ...
new energy for a new era!

Forest News website...
is powered by clean, reliable solar electrons.

© 1998-2011 • EcoSystems
contact info